IS IT TIME TO PAY BACK THE POLITICAL DONORS?

By Dewey R. Wotring

June 18, 2008

Has the time finally come for Judge Murner  to begin paying back all of the developers and other beneficiaries of development for donating to his campaign for county judge?  That certainly appears to be the case.

 Two different incidents indicate that developers are being let off the hook instead of being appropriately held responsible for their actions.  First, let's consider the planning and zoning commission. The cost to operate the planning and zoning commission is over $500,000 per year while fees collected total only approximately $40,000.  I believe that it is safe to say that the developers pay the majority of those fees as well they should since they get the most benefit from the fees. However, the amount of fees of which has been being collected simply is not enough. Those fees must be raised and made more equitable. There is no need for the taxpayers continue to support this operation

 With that in mind planning and zoning decided to raise their fees. The interesting thing is that they believed that the developers and realtors should have  major input into how those fees were raised. This was stated in open fiscal court on June 17, 2008. There was no mention made of consulting any ordinary citizens about those fees.  God forbid that we take a chance of hurting the feelings of the developers.  Plus the fees will still amount to less than $100,000 per year.  This means that the taxpayers will continue to fund an agency that primarily benefits developers.

 The second instance that comes to mind is the storm water tax which Judge Duane Murner intends to place upon the residents and businesses of Oldham County.  He will tell you that this tax is a result of federal mandates.  That is partially true. But many of the things required by the federal mandates are things which counties all over the United States have customarily taken care of and considered as part of the cost of running a government.  Some of those things would include cleaning ditches along highways, cleaning small waterways which handle storm water runoff and being careful of their own disposal of pollutants.  A second part of the storm water mandates is to educate the public regarding the control of storm water runoff.  This information is essentially provided to the county for distribution by the Commonwealth Water Education Project and the Kentucky Environmental Education Council.  What I believe to be the most expensive part of the mandates is the requirement to control construction sites that exceed one acre during the construction and subsequent to the completion of the construction. In Oldham County the majority of that type of construction would be the result of housing developments. The county is already cleaning up behind developers after the developments have been completed. Besides more stringent regulations would eliminate some of the need for the county to correcr mistakes made by developers.

 The county has contracted with two consultants regarding the storm water mandates.  The last consultant was paid a fee of $250,000 and the consultant  has told the county that for approximately three dollars per month per household the county could meet the mandates. The fees would amount to approximately $750,000 annually.  Frankly the county is already spending over $500,000 for storm water control from a budget that is balanced, balanced by the doubling of the insurance premium tax.  Thus, the remaining $250,000 could be raised  with a tax increase of one dollar per month per household.

 However, Judge Murner is not happy with one dollar or three dollars per month. He wants five dollars per month per household.  As a matter of fact, Judge Murner wants every tax dollar that he can squeeze from the public.  He has yet to say why he wants that much money.  My bet is that he knows he is beholding to the developers and he intends to repay them.  Moreover, why did Judge Murner waste a quarter of a million dollars on a consultant if he knows more than they know.  Would you go to a doctor and not listen to him/her?  Yes, "payback" time has come.